On this page
Problem 1: a sibling living in the house will not leave
Change one fact: Michael moved in with Mom two years before she died. After her death he stays, pays nothing, and says Mom wanted him to have the house. The will or trust says equal thirds.
Why it happens
- It has been his home, and he may have been Mom's caregiver.
- He treats a spoken promise as if it were a legal right.
- No one put anything in writing while Mom was alive.
What it costs the others
- The house cannot be shown or sold.
- The estate keeps paying the mortgage, taxes and insurance.
What can be done
- While the estate or trust owns the house, Isabella, as executor or trustee, controls it. She can agree in writing that Michael stays for a set time and pays rent, or charge the value of his stay against his share.
- If he refuses, she gives proper written notice and, if needed, asks the court to remove him. She never changes the locks or removes his belongings herself.
- If the house was already deeded to all three children, Michael is a co-owner and cannot simply be evicted. The others would ask the court for a partition sale (Lesson 6).
- Often the best answer is a buyout: Michael keeps the house and pays his siblings (Lesson 6).
Problem 2: the person in charge will not share information
Change one fact: Isabella stops returning calls. A year passes. Audrey and Michael do not know what was sold, what was paid, or when they will receive anything.
What the law requires
- A trustee must keep beneficiaries reasonably informed and must account for money in and money out.
- An executor or administrator reports to the court and to the heirs.
- Neither may use estate or trust property for personal benefit.
What Audrey and Michael can do
- Ask in writing for information or an accounting, and keep a copy.
- If a trustee does not respond within 60 days, petition the probate court to order an accounting (Probate Code 17200).
- For serious problems, ask the court to remove the trustee (Probate Code 15642) or the executor, and to make her repay losses she caused.
Not getting along is not enough. Courts remove a trustee for reasons such as a breach of duty, failing to act, or unfitness, not because siblings dislike each other.
Problem 3: the trust was never funded
Change one fact: Carol signed a living trust, but the deed to the house was never changed. Title still reads "Carol, an unmarried woman."
- The trust does not control the house. A trust only governs what it owns.
- The pour-over will sends the house to the trust, but a will works only through probate. The family is back in Lesson 1.
- Possible rescue: if Carol's trust papers list the house as a trust asset, Jacob may ask the court to confirm that it belongs to the trust. This is often called a Heggstad petition (Probate Code 850). It is a court filing, but usually far shorter than a full probate.
- Prevention: after signing a trust, confirm that the new deed was recorded. For agents and appraisers: always read the vesting.
Problem 4: a beneficiary form is out of date
The company pays whoever is named on its form. The will and the trust do not change that.
| What the form says | What happens |
|---|---|
| Carol's IRA still names Robert, who died first, and no backup | Depending on the custodian's rules, the IRA often goes to her estate. It then passes through probate and the children lose the better inherited-IRA rules. |
| A life insurance policy still names a former spouse | In California, divorce cancels most beneficiary designations to a former spouse, but not life insurance. The former spouse can still be paid. |
| Only Isabella is named on the Schwab account "so she can divide it" | The account legally belongs to Isabella alone. Sharing it is her choice, and may count as a gift from her. |
Problem 5: someone contests the will or trust
Change one fact: two months before she died, Carol signed a new trust leaving the house to one child. The others believe she did not understand what she was signing.
Common grounds for a contest
- Lack of capacity: she could not understand what she owned or who her family was.
- Undue influence: someone pressured or manipulated her.
- Fraud or forgery.
- Improper signing, such as missing witnesses on a will.
Deadlines and limits
- Trust: generally 120 days after the trustee's notice is served (Lesson 2).
- Will: at the probate hearing, or generally within 120 days after the will is admitted.
- No-contest clause: a clause that cuts out anyone who contests. In California it is enforced only if the contest was brought without probable cause.
- Contests are expensive and slow. Many settle in mediation.
Problem 6: the original will cannot be found
- Probate normally requires the original signed will.
- If the original was last in Carol's possession and cannot be found, the law presumes she destroyed it on purpose to revoke it.
- A copy can sometimes be admitted if the family proves the will was not revoked.
- If that fails, the estate passes as if there were no will (Lesson 3).
- Prevention: keep the original in a known, safe place and tell the executor where it is.
Problem 7: property disappears before it is divided
Within days of the funeral, jewelry is gone, the car is being driven, and someone has used Mom's debit card.
- No one owns anything yet. Until the executor or trustee distributes it, property belongs to the estate or trust.
- A power of attorney ended at death. Using Mom's accounts after she died is not allowed, even to pay her bills.
- First-week steps protect everyone: change the locks, photograph the contents, and make a written inventory (Lesson 1).
- The person in charge is responsible. An executor or trustee who lets property walk away, or who pays heirs before debts and taxes, can be personally liable.
- The court can order property returned and, for bad-faith taking, can award extra damages.
Problem 8: a deadline was missed
Some deadlines can be fixed with a late filing. Others cannot. These are the ones from this series.
| Deadline | When | If it is missed |
|---|---|---|
| Lodge the original will | 30 days after learning of the death | The holder can be liable for harm caused by the delay |
| Trustee's notice to heirs and beneficiaries | 60 days after the death | The trustee can be liable for damages, and the 120-day contest clock does not start |
| Change in ownership statement (BOE-502-D) | Trust: 150 days after the death. Probate: by the time the Inventory and Appraisal is filed | A penalty can be added to the property tax bill |
| Inventory and Appraisal | 4 months after Letters are issued | The court can order it and may remove the personal representative |
| Child moves in and files the homeowners' exemption (Prop 19) | One year after the death | The house can be reassessed to market value |
| Yearly withdrawals from an inherited IRA | Each year, when required | A federal penalty tax on the amount not withdrawn |
| Deadline to contest a trust | Generally 120 days after the notice | The right to contest is usually lost |
How disputes get resolved
| Method | How it works | Cost and time |
|---|---|---|
| A family meeting | Everyone sees the same documents and numbers at the same time, often with the attorney or CPA present | Lowest |
| Mediation | A neutral mediator helps the family reach a written settlement | Moderate; often one or two days |
| Probate court petition | A judge decides: order an accounting, remove a trustee, confirm title, rule on a contest | Highest; months to years |
For real estate professionals: you take instructions from the person with legal authority, not from the loudest family member. If relatives disagree, pause and send them to the attorney. Do not choose sides, hold property for anyone, or give legal advice.
Prevention checklist
For the parent (see Lesson 7)
- Sign a will or trust, and fund the trust.
- Keep beneficiary forms current, with backups.
- Put any promise about the house in the documents, not just in conversation.
- Tell the family who is in charge and where the papers are.
For the executor or trustee
- Secure the house and make an inventory in the first week.
- Keep a calendar of every deadline.
- Use a separate estate or trust account and keep every receipt.
- Send the same written update to every heir, regularly.
- Put any agreement about living in the house in writing.
- Get appraisals from independent professionals.
Review quiz
- While the estate or trust owns the house, who decides whether a sibling may live there?
- The oldest sibling
- The executor or trustee
- The agent
- Whoever has the keys
- May an executor change the locks and remove an occupant's belongings herself?
- Yes, at any time
- No; she gives notice and uses the court process if needed
- Yes, after 30 days
- Only with the agent's approval
- The house was already deeded to all three children. How do two of them force a sale?
- Eviction
- A partition action
- A new will
- A Prop 19 claim
- A trustee ignores a written request for an accounting. What can beneficiaries do?
- Nothing
- Petition the court to order one
- Sell the house themselves
- Write a new trust
- What is a Heggstad petition used for?
- Removing a trustee
- Confirming that an asset left out of a trust belongs to it
- Contesting a will
- Lowering property tax
- A life insurance policy still names a former spouse. In California, the divorce:
- Automatically cancelled it
- Did not automatically cancel it
- Split it in half
- Sent it to probate
- How long does someone generally have to contest a trust after the trustee's notice?
- 30 days
- 60 days
- 120 days
- Two years
- When is a no-contest clause enforced in California?
- Always
- Never
- Only if the contest was brought without probable cause
- Only for trusts over $1 million
- The original will was kept by Carol and cannot be found. What does the law presume?
- It is still valid
- She revoked it
- The oldest child has it
- The court has it
- May a child keep using Mom's power of attorney to pay bills after her death?
- Yes, for 90 days
- Yes, until probate opens
- No, it ended at her death
- Only for the mortgage
Answer key
| # | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | b | The fiduciary controls estate or trust property |
| 2 | b | Self-help lockouts are not allowed |
| 3 | b | Co-owners use partition, not eviction |
| 4 | b | Probate Code 17200 |
| 5 | b | Probate Code 850 |
| 6 | b | Life insurance is excluded from the automatic rule |
| 7 | c | Probate Code 16061.7 and 16061.8 |
| 8 | c | Probate Code 21311 |
| 9 | b | The presumption of revocation for a lost will |
| 10 | c | An agent's authority ends at death |
Vocabulary
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Accounting | A written report of money received, money paid out and what remains |
| Breach of fiduciary duty | A failure by an executor or trustee to act honestly and carefully for the heirs or beneficiaries |
| Capacity | The mental ability to understand and sign a will or trust |
| Contest | A court challenge to the validity of a will or trust |
| Heggstad petition | A petition asking the court to confirm that an asset belongs to a trust |
| Mediation | A meeting with a neutral person who helps the parties reach a settlement |
| No-contest clause | A clause that penalizes a beneficiary who contests; enforced only when the contest lacked probable cause |
| Partition action | A court case by a co-owner to sell or divide property |
| Removal | A court order replacing an executor, administrator or trustee |
| Surcharge | A court order making a fiduciary personally repay a loss |
| Undue influence | Pressure that overcomes a person's free will in making a will, trust or gift |
| Unlawful detainer | The court process for removing an occupant from property |
Sources
- Talkov Law, Evicting a sibling from an inherited house in California
- Hackard Law, Real estate battles in trust litigation
- Probate Code 17200 (petitions about a trust, including an accounting)
- Probate Code 15642 (removing a trustee)
- Hackard Law, Trustee removal in California
- Bay Legal, Section 850 and Heggstad petitions
- Bay Legal, Probate Code 859 and property taken in bad faith
- Probate Code 5040 (nonprobate transfers to a former spouse)
- Bay Legal, Contesting a trust (Probate Code 16061.8)
- Bay Legal, Contesting a will (Probate Code 8270)
- Probate Code 21311 (no-contest clauses)
- Probate Code 6124 (lost will presumed revoked)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 480 (change in ownership statement deadlines)
Disclosure: please consult a professional
This study guide is for teaching purposes only. The people, Seabrook and Harbor County are fictional. It is not legal, tax, accounting, financial or appraisal advice, and it does not create a professional relationship.
Disputes turn on their exact facts, documents and deadlines, and deadlines to act can be short. Anyone involved in an estate or trust dispute should consult a California-licensed probate or trust litigation attorney promptly.
Information is current as of November 15, 2026.