The Learning Ledger

For education only, not legal or tax advice. The family and places are fictional. Read the disclosure.

Lesson 6: Keeping the house

“What if we don't want to sell?”

Lesson 6 of 8. About 10 minutes to read, plus a 10-question review quiz.

Audrey wants to move into Mom's house. Michael wonders about renting it out. Keeping an inherited house is possible, but the property tax, the buyout and the income tax each work differently depending on what the family does with it.

The most important rule is Proposition 19: a child keeps Mom's low property tax value only if the child moves in, and only up to a limit.

Three choices for Carol's $900,000 house
Property taxIncome tax
Audrey moves inher principal residenceKeeps Mom's low value, if she files on timeNone while she lives there
The children rent it outReassessed to $900,000Rent is income; depreciation on the stepped-up basis
Sell itLesson 5The buyer pays tax on the new priceLittle or no gain, because of the step-up

Carol's property tax value was about $210,000. At roughly 1%, that is about $2,100 a year instead of about $9,000.

On this page
  1. Prop 19 rules
  2. The value limit
  3. Buying out siblings
  4. Renting it out
  5. Owning it together
  6. The mortgage
  7. Selling later
  8. Which appraisals are needed
  9. Review quiz
  10. Vocabulary
  11. Sources
  12. Disclosure

Proposition 19: the rules for a child who moves in

A death is a change in ownership, so the house would normally be reassessed to market value. Prop 19 lets a child keep the parent's taxable value on the family home, if every condition below is met.

Prop 19 parent-child exclusion: conditions and deadlines
RequirementDeadlineNotes
It was the parent's principal residenceAt the date of deathRentals and vacation homes do not qualify.
The child moves in and makes it her principal residenceWithin one year of the deathIf several children inherit, only one has to live there.
File the homeowners' exemption claim (BOE-266)Within one year of the deathFiled late, the tax savings start later instead of from the date of death.
File the exclusion claim (BOE-19-P)Within three years of the death, or before the house is transferred to someone else, whichever comes firstFiled with the county assessor.
Keep living thereOngoingIf the child moves out, the house is reassessed. If another sibling who inherited moves in within one year, the exclusion can continue.

The executor or trustee also files the Change in Ownership Statement, Death of Real Property Owner (BOE-502-D). In a trust it is due within 150 days of the death. In a probate it is due by the time the Inventory and Appraisal is filed.

The value limit

The exclusion is not unlimited. It covers the parent's taxable value plus about $1 million of extra market value. For deaths from February 16, 2025 through February 15, 2027, the added amount is $1,044,586.

Prop 19 value limit: two examples
Carol's houseA more valuable house
Parent's taxable value$210,000$300,000
Plus the added amount$1,044,586$1,044,586
Protected limit$1,254,586$1,344,586
Market value at death$900,000$1,500,000
Market value above the limit$0$155,414
Child's new taxable value$210,000$455,414

The market value in this test is the value on the date of death, which is one more reason the family needs a date-of-death appraisal.

Buying out siblings without losing the tax break

Audrey inherits only one-third of the house. How she gets the other two-thirds matters a great deal for property tax.

The trap: buying directly from her siblings

If Isabella and Michael each receive a one-third interest and then sell it to Audrey, those are sales between siblings, not transfers from a parent. Sibling-to-sibling transfers have no exclusion, so two-thirds of the house can be reassessed to market value.

The usual solution: let the estate or trust do it

The executor or trustee distributes the whole house to Audrey and other assets or cash of equal value to her siblings. The house then goes from parent to child in one step.

When there is not enough cash: a simple example

A trust holds one asset, a $900,000 house with no loan, for three children. Each share is $300,000.

  1. The trust allows the trustee to give different assets to different beneficiaries (a non-pro-rata distribution).
  2. The trust borrows $600,000 from an outside lender, secured by the house. The loan must be made to the trust, not to Audrey personally.
  3. The trustee pays Isabella and Michael $300,000 each from the loan.
  4. The trustee deeds the house to Audrey, subject to the $600,000 loan.
  5. Audrey refinances the loan in her own name, moves in within a year and files her Prop 19 claims.

Plan before anything is signed. Whether this works depends on the trust or will, the lender and the county assessor. Jacob sets up the steps in the right order, and the buyout price comes from an appraisal everyone agrees on.

Renting it out

If no child lives there, Prop 19 gives no protection. The house is reassessed to its $900,000 market value, and it becomes a business for income tax.

Property tax

  • New taxable value: about $900,000.
  • Tax rises from about $2,100 to about $9,000 a year, plus local charges.
  • A supplemental tax bill arrives for the change, dated back to the date of death.

Practical points

  • Change the insurance to a landlord policy.
  • Decide who manages it and who pays for repairs.
  • Check the mortgage (see below).

Income tax and depreciation

  • Rent is taxable income to the owners.
  • The owners depreciate the building, not the land, starting from the stepped-up basis, over 27.5 years.
  • Sample figures: if 40% of the $900,000 is building, that is $360,000 divided by 27.5, or about $13,090 of depreciation a year, shared by the owners.
  • The CPA needs a land and building split. An appraiser can provide one.
  • Depreciation taken is taxed back when the property is sold.

Owning it together

If the house is distributed to all three children, they usually hold title as tenants in common, one-third each.

  • Each owner can use the whole property and owes a share of taxes, insurance and repairs.
  • Each owner can sell or leave her share to someone else, including a spouse or children.
  • Any owner can ask a court to force a sale, called a partition action. California law generally gives the other owners a chance to buy that owner's share at an appraised value first.
  • Put it in writing. A co-ownership agreement covers who pays what, who can live there, and how a buyout price is set.

Rule of thumb: co-owning a parent's house works when everyone wants the same thing. It rarely lasts when one sibling needs cash.

The mortgage

  • Carol's $80,000 loan stays on the house until it is paid off.
  • If Audrey lives there, federal law generally stops the lender from calling the loan due because a relative inherited the home. She asks the servicer to treat her as the successor in interest and keeps paying.
  • If it becomes a rental or goes into a company name, that protection may not apply. Ask the servicer or refinance.
  • A buyout loan replaces the old mortgage.

Selling later

If Audrey sells her home years later

  • Her basis is her inherited share at the date-of-death value plus what she paid for the rest, plus improvements.
  • After owning and living there two of the last five years, she can exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 if married and filing jointly.

If the rental is sold later

  • Gain is measured from the $900,000 stepped-up basis, reduced by depreciation taken.
  • There is no home-sale exclusion for a rental.
  • The owners keep the date-of-death appraisal for as long as they own the property.

Which appraisals does the family need?

Appraisals used when a family keeps an inherited house
AppraisalEffective dateUsed for
Date-of-death appraisalCarol's date of deathStepped-up basis, the Prop 19 value test, and the starting point for depreciation
Current-value appraisalClose to the buyout dateA fair buyout price if values changed since the death
Land and building allocationDate of deathDepreciation on a rental
Lender's appraisalLoan dateThe buyout loan or refinance; ordered by the lender

Review quiz

  1. Under Prop 19, a child keeps the parent's taxable value only if the house:
    1. Is rented to a relative
    2. Becomes the child's principal residence within one year
    3. Is sold within one year
    4. Is worth under $500,000
  2. The homeowners' exemption claim should be filed within:
    1. 30 days
    2. 150 days
    3. One year of the death
    4. Five years
  3. The BOE-19-P exclusion claim is due within:
    1. One year
    2. Three years, or before a transfer to someone else
    3. Ten years
    4. No deadline
  4. Carol's taxable value is $210,000 and the market value is $900,000. What is Audrey's new taxable value if she qualifies?
    1. $210,000
    2. $555,000
    3. $900,000
    4. $1,254,586
  5. Three children inherit and rent the house out. What happens to the property tax?
    1. Nothing
    2. It is reassessed to market value
    3. It is cut in thirds
    4. It is frozen for five years
  6. Why is buying a sibling's share directly a problem?
    1. It is illegal
    2. Sibling-to-sibling transfers have no reassessment exclusion
    3. It cancels the step-up
    4. It requires probate
  7. In the buyout example, who must the outside loan be made to?
    1. Audrey
    2. Isabella
    3. The trust
    4. The county
  8. What part of a rental house can be depreciated?
    1. Land only
    2. Building only
    3. Land and building
    4. Nothing, after a step-up
  9. What is a partition action?
    1. A property tax appeal
    2. A court case by a co-owner to force a sale or division
    3. A type of appraisal
    4. A trust amendment
  10. What happens if Audrey moves out three years later and no sibling moves in?
    1. Nothing
    2. The house is reassessed
    3. She owes inheritance tax
    4. The step-up is lost
Answer key
Answer key for the review quiz
#AnswerWhy
1bProp 19 covers only a family home the child lives in
2cFiling within one year applies the savings from the date of death
3bThree years, or before transfer to a third party
4a$900,000 is under the $1,254,586 limit
5bNo exclusion for a rental
6bOnly parent-child (and some grandparent-grandchild) transfers are excluded
7cSo the house passes from the parent's trust to the child
8bLand is not depreciable
9bAny co-owner may ask the court for it
10bThe exclusion lasts only while a qualifying child lives there

Vocabulary

Vocabulary terms and definitions
TermDefinition
BOE-19-PClaim for the parent-child reassessment exclusion under Prop 19
BOE-266Claim for the homeowners' property tax exemption
Change in ownershipAn event, such as a death or sale, that triggers property tax reassessment unless an exclusion applies
DepreciationYearly income tax deduction for the building portion of a rental, over 27.5 years for residential property
Factored base year valueThe Prop 13 taxable value, raised no more than 2% a year
Non-pro-rata distributionGiving beneficiaries different assets of equal value instead of a share of each asset
Partition actionA court case in which a co-owner asks for the property to be sold or divided
Principal residenceThe home a person actually lives in most of the time
Proposition 192020 California measure limiting the parent-child exclusion to a family home the child lives in, with a value limit
ReassessmentResetting a property's taxable value to current market value
Supplemental assessmentAn extra tax bill for the change in value from the date ownership changed
Tenants in commonCo-owners who each hold a share they can sell or leave to others

Disclosure: please consult a professional

This study guide is for teaching purposes only. The people, Seabrook and Harbor County are fictional, and the dollar figures are samples. It is not legal, tax, accounting, financial or appraisal advice, and it does not create a professional relationship.

Property tax results depend on the county assessor's review, the exact way title passes, and filing deadlines. The Prop 19 dollar limit changes every two years. Before acting, consult a California-licensed estate attorney, a CPA or enrolled agent, the county assessor's office, and a state-certified real estate appraiser.

Information is current as of November 15, 2026.